I love both the lip liner and the amp it gloss, the colours are rich and beautiful. I however do not like them together unfortunately. The lip liner is water based and the gloss is oil base so when you put them together the gloss makes a mess of the liner. I use them separately, the lip I blend almost lip a lipstick with a tiny bit of non oil gloss. The amp it gloss I wear on it's own without the liner. The liner is creamy, soft, pigmented and definitely worth buying. When purchasing I would go in with the exceptions of using them individually.